A 2:30 a.m. call for a woman who fell while under the influence highlighted the difficult balance first responders face when someone refuses treatment but is clearly not safe to be left alone.
Police and EMS were dispatched after reports the woman had injured her leg. Fire Department medics arrived first and determined she needed help but refused transport to the hospital. The problem: while paramedics can’t legally force someone to go to the hospital against their will, they also aren’t allowed to leave a person obviously incapacitated in a dangerous situation.
At the time, all Portsmouth Police units were tied up, so dispatch attempted to reach the Scioto County Sheriff’s Office and New Boston Police Department for backup. After about 30 minutes, deputies were able to respond, and they gave the woman a ride home to ensure she was safe.
The Bigger Picture
First responders say these situations are common — particularly late at night when alcohol or drugs are involved. Medics face tough decisions when patients refuse care: respect their rights while still making sure they don’t endanger themselves or others.
Officials remind residents that calling 911 is always the right choice if someone appears hurt, intoxicated, or unable to care for themselves. Police and EMS may not always be able to make someone accept treatment, but they will always work together to find the safest possible outcome.