Scioto County commissioners say they’ve spent much of the year asking county offices to tighten their belts. Most have cooperated, but one department is creating a particularly big headache.
The Scioto County Sheriff’s Office is on track to exceed its budget by nearly $1 million, and commissioners say they don’t know where they’ll find the money to cover it.
At Thursday’s meeting, Commissioner Scottie Powell said the county had just approved approximately $222,000 for Sheriff’s Office payroll and benefits to get the department through November.
But another bill is looming.
The Sheriff’s Office has an outstanding request for $426,000 for December, and Powell said the county may not have enough money to pay it.
“Quite frankly, I don’t know that we can cover it,” Powell said.
Where’s the Money Going?
Powell said the Sheriff’s Office accounts for roughly one-third of the county’s budget, making it the biggest concern as commissioners try to close the year without running out of money.
“Currently the biggest heartburn is the Sheriff’s Office,” Powell said.
Commissioners have been talking with the sheriff about expenses involving the jail, road patrol and administrative operations.
Powell also pointed to ongoing union contract negotiations and proposed wage increases.
He said those requests are difficult to consider when other county employees may face another year without raises.
“Some of the requests that we saw come over with different wage increases, when the rest of the county is probably going to still be on a freeze, is pretty hard math to figure out,” Powell said.
“Because the money’s not there.”
Powell said the Sheriff’s Office was already approximately $300,000 over budget in November, with the additional December request potentially pushing the total overrun close to $1 million.
Commissioners say the department has been warned repeatedly that spending needs to come down.
The Extra Money Has Run Out
Overspending by the Sheriff’s Office isn’t new, according to Powell.
In previous years, commissioners were able to find ways to cover expenses that exceeded the department’s original budget.
But those solutions depended heavily on temporary sources of money.
The county used federal pandemic relief funds, opioid settlement money and grants to help cover costs.
Those funds allowed commissioners to balance the books even when departments spent more than originally budgeted.
Now much of that one-time funding is gone.
“That math is not there,” Powell said.
And commissioners say the Sheriff’s Office hasn’t reduced expenses enough to make up the difference.
Merit Smith said commissioners warned county officeholders at the beginning of the year that financial trouble was coming.
“We’ve been saying this from the beginning of the year that we saw a lot of this coming, and we asked the officeholders to try their best to reduce that spending,” Smith said.
He said most offices have responded by cutting costs and reporting their savings.
But small reductions don’t make much difference when a department is hundreds of thousands of dollars over budget.
“When you’re a million dollars over, which is what the Sheriff’s Department is, to reduce $10,000 or whatever through the course of the year, that’s very small compared to what they’ve gone over budget,” Smith said.
Commissioners Push Back on Blame
Powell expressed frustration with the idea that commissioners should automatically be responsible for finding additional money whenever an office exceeds its budget.
He described the situation as a “game of chicken.”
“Well, the commissioners didn’t give me enough money, so we have to do X, Y, Z,” Powell said, describing the argument he says commissioners hear.
“No, we gave you the money. You went over.”
Powell said county offices receive their budgets at the beginning of the year and are responsible for managing spending within those limits.
“You set an expectation for your staff that there would be money there, and they went over. Now it falls on us to figure out whether we can pay it or not.”
Commissioners also indicated they’re skeptical of requests for extra money when their own calculations suggest an office should have enough to finish the year.
Smith said commissioners don’t intend to approve additional money simply to fund one-time pay increases.
Children’s Services Adds Another Problem
The Sheriff’s Office isn’t the only financial crisis facing the county.
Powell said the county is also dealing with a major funding shortfall involving Children’s Protective Services.
“We have a couple million in CPS funding that’s probably not going to get covered this year,” he said.
That means commissioners are facing pressure from two major spending areas at the same time.
And unlike a road project or building improvement that might be delayed, expenses involving law enforcement, jail operations and child protection can be difficult to postpone.
Powell said the combination makes it increasingly likely the county will finish the year short of the money needed to cover its obligations.
‘You Can’t Get Blood From a Turnip’
Commissioner Will Mault said he’s been working with Powell to understand the county’s finances and the challenges ahead.
But he summed up the situation with a familiar saying.
“You can’t get blood from a turnip.”
Commissioners have already begun making difficult decisions as the budget crunch affects county operations.
They recently rejected a $526,000 bid to repair the county jail roof because the price exceeded available grant funding. Instead, they’re seeking bids for a smaller portion of the work.
They’ve also warned that higher-paying jobs connected to major regional development projects are making it harder for the county to keep experienced employees.
Now the Sheriff’s Office’s December funding request presents an even more immediate problem.
Commissioners say they’re still waiting to hear what steps the sheriff plans to take to control spending.
And with just weeks left in the year, the question is no longer simply how to balance next year’s budget.
It’s whether the county can cover the bills it already has.





















































































