Portsmouth City Council is taking the next step in its push to determine whether the city really needs two Municipal Court judges.
At Monday’s meeting, council is scheduled to give a first reading to a resolution that would formally send the Ohio Supreme Court’s review of Portsmouth Municipal Court to State Rep. Justin Pizzulli and ask him to consider legislation reducing the city’s two-judge system.
In other words, City Hall is preparing to take the question to Columbus.
The resolution does not eliminate a judgeship.
City Council can’t do that on its own.
Ohio law specifically provides Portsmouth Municipal Court with two full-time judges — one judgeship dating back to 1951 and a second added in 1985. Changing that structure would require action by the Ohio General Assembly.
That’s where Pizzulli comes in.
The Wheelersburg-area lawmaker represents House District 90, which includes all of Scioto County.
Remember This Fight?
SCDN told you last month that City Hall was preparing to revive the long-running debate over whether Portsmouth still needs two Municipal Court judges.
And this is far from the first time the question has come up.
In 2024, the city asked the Ohio Supreme Court to study Portsmouth Municipal Court and determine whether its workload justified keeping both judgeships.
The answer was not exactly a slam dunk for either side.
The Supreme Court review found the court was operating at a high level, with no evidence of growing backlogs or widespread delays.
It also warned that cutting Portsmouth down to a single judge would leave that judge with a relatively large caseload and could make it harder to maintain the court’s current performance.
At the same time, the review noted that Scioto County’s population is expected to continue declining, which could eventually reduce the number of cases coming through the court.
That left City Hall with ammunition for the argument that two judges may eventually be more than Portsmouth needs — but also a pretty significant warning that one judge would still have a lot of work to do.
And There Are A Lot of Cases
Portsmouth Municipal Court has previously reported handling more than:
3,000 criminal cases, 10,000 traffic cases and 2,000 civil cases in an average year.
Its probation department has supervised more than 2,000 defendants.
When SCDN last examined the issue, one day’s court calendar alone listed 94 cases.
Portsmouth Municipal Court’s jurisdiction also extends throughout Scioto County, not merely the city limits.
So eliminating a judge does not eliminate any of that work.
It simply changes how many permanent judges are available to handle it.
Ohio law does allow the chief justice to assign another sitting or retired judge temporarily when a municipal court’s workload requires additional help.
That raises one of the practical questions that has followed the proposal from the beginning:
How much money does Portsmouth actually save if one permanent judge is eliminated but visiting judges have to be brought in regularly to keep up?
What Monday’s Resolution Actually Does
The new resolution lays out a fairly specific path.
If council ultimately adopts it, the city would formally send the Supreme Court review and supporting workload information to Pizzulli.
Council would ask him to examine whether the current two-court structure remains necessary based on both current and historical caseloads.
Then comes the important part.
The resolution specifically asks Pizzulli to consider “pursuing, sponsoring, supporting, or otherwise facilitating” legislation that would allow Portsmouth’s municipal court structure to be reduced from two courts to a system more consistent with its demonstrated workload.
That is a considerably bigger step than simply talking about the idea at a council conference.
It amounts to an official request that Portsmouth’s state representative take the issue to the General Assembly.
The resolution also stresses that council is not attempting to interfere with judges or individual cases.
The request deals only with the number and statutory structure of the courts.
The State Created the Second Judgeship
There is a reason the city needs help from Columbus.
Ohio Revised Code specifically says Portsmouth Municipal Court has two full-time judges — one first elected in 1951 and another first elected in 1985.
That means the second seat isn’t something City Council can simply erase from the city budget.
The General Assembly would have to amend state law.
And that’s exactly what this resolution asks Pizzulli to consider doing.
A Debate With Plenty of Baggage
The last attempt to tackle the issue became much more than a discussion about spreadsheets and caseloads.
Municipal Court Judges Steven Mowery and Russell Kegley pushed back against arguments that their court was responsible for Portsmouth’s financial pressures.
The judges instead pointed to the city’s costly relocation and renovation of the four-story municipal building, arguing that decisions made during that project helped push costs millions of dollars beyond earlier estimates.
City officials, meanwhile, continued questioning whether maintaining two elected judges was justified by the court’s workload.
The dispute became increasingly bitter and eventually intertwined with other controversies involving City Hall and Municipal Court.
So while the wording of Monday’s resolution is dry and procedural, there is a whole lot of history sitting behind it.
One Judge? Columbus Would Have to Say Yes
Even if council passes the resolution, nothing immediately changes at Municipal Court.
Pizzulli would first have to decide whether to pursue legislation.
The Ohio House and Senate would then have to approve a statutory change, and that legislation would have to become law.
Until then, Portsmouth remains a two-judge Municipal Court because that is what Ohio law currently requires.
Monday’s measure is scheduled for its first reading, meaning council is beginning the formal legislative process rather than taking a final vote on the court structure itself.
But after years of debate, City Hall is no longer simply asking:
Do we really need two judges?
It is preparing to ask Columbus to do something about it.

















































































